Login Contribute Volunteer

Get email from Jon Corzine

Go to the campaign web site
Supporter Blogs
Corzine Connection
Supporters Diaries
The Campaign Blogs
On The Trail
News
Miscellaneous
The Issues Blogs
Economic Growth
Environment
Ethics in Government
Health Care
Property Taxes
Seniors
Other Issues
Blogging the GOP
DC Republicans
Doug Forrester

www.flickr.com

Owen is unfit for the federal bench

The problem with Owen is not so much that she is an "extreme right-wing judge", but rather that she is exactly the sort of "activist" judge who creates law in her opinions that the Republicans in Congress complain about.  Her opinions have been criticized in the harshest terms by such "progressives" as Alberto Gonzales and John Cornyn.

Here are some of the things that majority jurists have written about her dissents:
-In FM Properties v. City of Austin, the majority calls her dissent, "nothing more than inflammatory rhetoric."
-In Montgomery Independent School District v. Davis, the majority (which included Alberto Gonzales and two other Bush appointees) is quite explicit about its view that Owen's position disregards the law, saying that "nothing in the statute requires" what she says it does, and that, "the dissenting opinion's misconception . . . stems from its disregard of the procedural elements the Legislature established," and that the "dissenting opinion not only disregards the procedural limitations in the statute but takes a position even more extreme than that argued for by the board. . ."
-In In re Jane Doe, the majority includes an extremely unusual section explaining its view of the proper role of judges, admonishing the dissent joined by Justice Owen for going beyond its duty to interpret the law in an attempt to fashion policy, and in a separate concurrence, Justice Alberto Gonzales says that to the construe law as the dissent did, "would be an unconscionable act of judicial activism."
-In Weiner v. Wasson, in what reads as a lecture to the dissent, then-Justice John Cornyn (now Senator Cornyn) explains stare decisis on behalf of the majority, in language that would be used with a beginning law student.
-In In re Jane Doe 3, Justice Enoch writes specifically to rebuke Owen and her follow dissenters for misconstruing the legislature's definition of the sort of abuse that may occur when parents are notified of a minor's intent to have an abortion, saying, "abuse is abuse; it is neither to be trifled with nor its severity to be second guessed."

Judge Owen is the lunatic fringe of jurists and has no business being nominated to a lifetime, federal post.  I can't even begin to imagine what the motivation of the White House could be for such a nomination except to do as much damage to the judiciary as possible.  It's one thing to put an unfit jurist on the bench at a lower level in the food-chain, where her opinions could be reversed, to pay off a political debt, but this nomination smacks less of court-packing than arson.

by gdfrogsdong on May 19 at 8:04 AM EST

Login

Sign in here if you already have a Corzine Connection account.



I Forgot My Password

Action Center

  • Build Support
  • Plan/Find Events
  • Contact the Media
  • Raise Money

Blog Archive


Find Events Near You

Jersey Blogs

  • Read our Disclaimer
  • The Bray (NJ Dems)
  • Democrats 2000
  • Mercer County DFA
  • NJ Democratic State Committee
  • NJ for Democracy
  • Ocean County DFA
  • Progressive Bloggers of NJ
  • A Cautious Man
  • Angry Democrat Forum
  • Bad Hair Blog
  • Barista
  • Bayshore Journalista
  • Big Windbag
  • Blog for Highland Park
  • Brilliant at Breakfast
  • Buzzmachine
  • Call and Answer
  • Coffee Grounds
  • Daily Scoop
  • Dump Mike
  • Dynamobuzz
  • Everyone is Included
  • Fitszo
  • Forty Four
  • Frogsdong
  • Gigglechick
  • I am Bill Power
  • In an Alternate Universe
  • Heather Fink
  • Hurricane James
  • Jersey Beat
  • JerseyBredFilly (kos diary)
  • Jersey Politics
  • Katespot
  • Latino Pundit
  • Liberal Marine's Progressive
  • Levy 2020
  • Manzella News
  • Maru the Crankpot
  • Media in Trouble
  • Mister Snitch
  • Nathan Rudy
  • New Jersey Eminent Domain Law Blog
  • NJ Politiko
  • NJ Tipster
  • NJ for Feingold
  • NJ for Clark
  • Olfactory Hues
  • OurSenate
  • Parkway Rest Stop
  • Patridiot Watch
  • Perspective
  • Plainfield Area Equality
  • Plainfield Plain Talker
  • Poetic Leanings
  • Politics 5
  • Princeton Drinking Liberally
  • Professor Kim
  • Rix Mix
  • Sherrils Myria of Musings
  • Skaroff
  • Subcutaneous
  • Super Hanc Petram
  • Tammany on the Hudson
  • The Atlantic Highlands Muse
  • The Contrarian
  • The One True Tami
  • Terminus
  • The Jersey Side
  • The Long Cut
  • The Opinion Mill
  • The Peninsula Pundit
  • The Yellin Report
  • Tris McCall
  • TurnpikeFeminist
  • Underdog Democrat
  • United Left
  • Xpatriated Texan
  • Zucchini Chronicles
  • Suggest a blog

Jersey Media

  • Asbury Park Press
  • Atlantic City Press
  • Bergen Record
  • Bridgeton News
  • Burlington County Times
  • Cranbury Press
  • Courier News
  • Courier Post
  • Daily Journal
  • Daily News
  • Daily Record
  • Express Times
  • Gloucester County Times
  • Home News Tribune
  • Jersey Journal
  • Jersey Politics
  • New Jersey Herald
  • New Jersey Reporter
  • Newsday
  • NJ.com
  • Ocean County Observer
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • PoliticsNJ
  • Star Ledger
  • The Record
  • The Two Rivers Times
  • Today's Sunbeam
  • Trenton Times
  • Trentonian
  • Suggest a media link

Jersey Stuff

  • Garden State Parkway Pics
  • New Jersey Film Festival
  • NJ Media Corps
  • Weird NJ
  • Wikipedia - New Jersey
  • Wikipedia - New Jersey History
  • Wikipedia - New Jersey Senate
  • Wikipedia - Doug Forrester
  • Wikipedia - Jon Corzine
  • Suggest Jersey stuff